BMW vs. Jaguar Reliability
I am a serial entrepreneur and a consumer advocate. When I’m not helping car buyers, I love working on ventures that have a positive impact.
I run a cause marketing agency and serve on the board of Vayu Global Health where we are disrupting the medical industry and preventing the needless deaths of mothers and babies during childbirth.
Jaguars are not as popular as BMW, but it's not a bad idea to study their reliability and decide which one is best for you.
Both Jaguar and BMW are luxury brands, so you are assured of getting high-end vehicles, great performance, and premium features.
However, both brands have different approaches to their designs and production, which impacts their vehicles' reliability.
As a matter of fact, BMW is more reliable than Jaguar. BMW offers higher safety ratings, cheaper repair and maintenance costs, and higher reliability ratings. The resale value is also higher on BMW compared to Jaguar.
BMW and Jaguar have a lot of cars in different segments, so you should expect different performances across different models. Both brands have vehicles that deliver superb handling, dynamics, and power; however, for the sake of long-term ownership, you should go for BMW.
Here's all you should know about BMW vs. Jaguar reliability and how to make better choices.
Table of Contents
BMW vs. Jaguar Reliability: A Detailed Comparison
| Features | BMW | Jaguar |
| Design | ||
| Engine and Performance | ||
| Safety | ||
| Repair and Maintenance Cost | ||
| Gas Mileage | ||
| Technology | ||
| Durability |
BMW vs. Jaguar Reliability: Which Is Better?
Jaguar isn't an entirely bad brand. Their vehicles are stylish, the performance is superb, and you get a blend of luxury and power. However, irrespective of how good Jaguar vehicles are when compared to BMW, it is obvious that BMW is better.
According to RepairPal, BMW has a reliability rating of 2.5/5.0, ranking 30th out of 32 car brands. This is better than Jaguar, which ranks 29th out of 32 car brands with a reliability rating of 2.5/5.0.
The 2022 consumer reports survey places BMW in the third position, while Jaguar is missing from the list due to insufficient data or the low model count. This is a similar case to the 2022 JD Power Dependability survey, where BMW also ranks higher than Jaguar.
Irrespective of the fact that BMW has higher reliability ratings, it is important to study the features of vehicles from both brands, comparing them with factors that will help you decide which is more reliable.
BMW and Jaguar ain't the best car brands in terms of reliability, but BMW is a few steps above Jaguar. There are a lot of areas where BMW outperforms Jaguar. For instance, you are getting cheaper repair and maintenance costs from BMW, higher safety ratings, and a cheaper overall cost of ownership.
However, Jaguar offers a longer warranty coverage. This can shield you from a lot of expenses for a long time. With Jaguar, you are getting a new vehicle limited warranty of 5 years or 60,000 miles. This is compared to BMW, which offers 4 years/50,000 miles.
There's also longer corrosion coverage, complimentary maintenance, and a certified pre-owned car (CPO) warranty on Jaguar vehicles compared to BMWs.
The differences in design, performance, and overall design dynamics depend on your chosen model. This also refers to gas mileage and engine strength, although BMW is better when it comes to durability.
BMW vs. Jaguar Reliability: Design
Both BMW and Jaguar are known for their excellent design, building luxury cars that make a statement. Whether you are choosing BMW or Jaguar, you are assured of getting a vehicle that stands out, a beauty to behold.
However, these brands deploy different approaches to design. These different design philosophies play a great role in defining what you should expect from BMW and Jaguar designs.
For Jaguar, you are getting traditional British designs, blending with modern styles. Jaguar's design philosophy borders around the need to deploy good stances, beautiful lines, clear and pure surfaces, and great proportions to produce cars that are enticing and pleasing to the eye.
The Jaguar brand has undergone lots of upgrades and improvements to redefine what its vehicles stand for. This is because the brand has battled with a lot of reliability issues in the past.
On the other hand, BMW is focused on building cars that help you enjoy the sheer pleasure of driving. You are getting sleek and modern designs with great emphasis on performance and sportiness.
You are getting cutting-edge technology, driver-oriented systems, and bold durable frames.
You must understand that the design of BMW and Jaguar is dependent on the models that you are choosing. For instance, the BMW X3 SUV adopts a classy and elegant design, while the Jaguar F-Pace is sporty and aggressive.
This also refers to the space on vehicles from these brands. The 2022 Jaguar F-Pace beats the BMW X3 with more rear legroom, more headroom, and cargo space, but the 2022 BMW 5-series offers more space than the 2022 Jaguar XF. The design reliability boils down to the model that you choose.
Irrespective of their differences, BMW and Jaguar are symbols of luxury, class, and sophistication. You are assured of getting these from any model that you choose from both brands.
Winner: Both
BMW vs. Jaguar Reliability: Engine and Performance:
To decide between BMW and Jaguar’s engines, it is important to figure out what your needs are and what your expectations are from an engine. Sometimes, most car brands sacrifice gas mileage in the bid to offer high performance and a burst of power.
In the case of BMW and Jaguar, while we believe that BMW offers more reliable engines than Jaguar, both brands offer relative performance and fuel economy. The fuel efficiency, speed, and power that you will get from a BMW or Jaguar car depends on the model that you choose.
For instance, the BMW 5-series has an engine that returns better horsepower than the 2022 Jaguar XF. However, both models are similar in terms of gas mileage.
The 2022 Jaguar F-Type engine returns better performance than the 2022 BMW 430, but the BMW 430 has better gas mileage than the Jaguar F-Type.
You don't need to crack your head trying to make a general decision for both brands. You can narrow your choices down by comparing the engines of models from both brands and then decide what your driving needs are. There are different engines tailored to address different styles and conditions, waiting for your selection.
If you must choose a Jaguar, we will advise that you avoid older models. This is because, unlike BMW, Jaguar has battled with many reliability issues and significant engine problems ranging from oil leaks to timing chain issues.
Winner: Both
BMW vs. Jaguar Reliability: Gas Mileage
Just as engine performance, gas mileage is relative to BMW and Jaguar. In some cases, you will find BMW with better fuel-efficient systems, and sometimes, Jaguar does it better - what you get depends on the model that you choose.
From an overall view, a close study of vehicles from both brands reveals that BMW offers better gas mileage. However, it is important to mention that there are some cases that Jaguar offers similar fuel efficiency as BMWs.
The BMW brand adopts aerodynamic designs, stop-start systems, plus different integrations that enhance fuel economy.
Let's take a closer view; the 2022 BMW 430 returns better gas mileage than the Jaguar F-Type, just as the BMW 3 series returns better gas mileage than Jaguar XF. However, the 2022 BMW 5 series and Jaguar XF have the same gas mileage of 25/33 MPG for city and highway rides.
Winner: Both
BMW vs. Jaguar Reliability: Safety and Technology
BMW takes a giant leap against Jaguar, producing vehicles that are relatively safer than Jaguars. On an overall scale, BMW earns higher safety ratings than Jaguar. However, it is important to mention that no matter how high the safety ratings of a brand is, it does not suffice the need to drive safely.
According to the 2022 IIHS safety rating, BMW has five cars earning the 2022 IIHS Top Safety(+) Award. This is compared to Jaguar, which doesn't even have any car earning the IIHS rating.
There are a lot of factors that influence Jaguar's absence in safety rating, one of which includes limited models available.
Irrespective of the high differences in safety between BMW and Jaguar, you are assured of getting advanced safety and technology features in their cars.
BMW employs an active protection system that features frontal collision warning, blind spot detection systems, and well-equipped driver assistance systems that keeps you in control.
From the integration of sensors for speed limits, GPS for navigation, and brake assists, there are enough safety features on BMW vehicles - features that you can rely on.
On the other hand, Jaguar isn't entirely left out in the race for safety, from the inclusion of rear parking aids, emergency braking, adaptive cruise control, lane departure warning, and lots more.
Although BMW beats Jaguar in terms of safety, it is important to mention that the safety features of these brands are relative. Some Jaguar models have safety ratings that you can rely on.
Winner: BMW
BMW vs. Jaguar Reliability: Repair and Maintenance Cost
The truth is that both BMW and Jaguar are super expensive to repair and maintain. The repair and maintenance cost of BMW and Jaguar is on the high side, but BMW isn't as expensive as Jaguar.
According to RepairPal, you are getting an average annual repair cost of $1123 on Jaguar, compared to BMW, which has only $968. However, the complexity and delicate nature of BMW cars will give you more reasons to visit the repair shop.
Jaguar has a 0.6 chance of visiting a repair shop and a 16% probability that the damage is severe. BMW has a 0.9 chance of visiting a repair shop and a 15% probability of severe damages. It is important to mention that most BMW issues require specialized attention.
Winner: BMW
Conclusion
Jaguar and BMW aren't our best options when it comes to reliable car brands, but they have impressive features that anyone can admire.
It is obvious that BMW is more reliable than Jaguar, but we advise you to compare the model you wish to buy. This includes test-driving the car to better understand what you should expect.
