Genesis vs BMW: Reliability Guide
I am a serial entrepreneur and a consumer advocate. When I’m not helping car buyers, I love working on ventures that have a positive impact.
I run a cause marketing agency and serve on the board of Vayu Global Health where we are disrupting the medical industry and preventing the needless deaths of mothers and babies during childbirth.
Reliability is one of the most important factors that every driver should consider when trying to buy a new car. You wouldn't want to spend so much on repairs and frequent breakdowns.
Genesis and BMW are superb car brands and are known for their excellent delivery in terms of luxury, performance, and style. However, there are a lot of differences that set these brands apart from each other.
In terms of overall reliability, Genesis is more reliable than BMW. With Genesis, you are getting cars that are cheaper to run, have better overall dependability, and are quite beneficial, especially if you are planning for long-term ownership.
Irrespective of the fact that BMW is the symbol of sporty rides, Genesis gives you some gold-level reliability standards. They are more durable, have cheaper repair and maintenance costs, and have higher safety ratings, with lesser tendencies to have major or minor repairs compared to BMWs.
In this blog, we will give you a detailed comparison of the Genesis vs. BMW reliability to guide you through making better market decisions.
Table of Contents
Genesis vs. BMW Reliability: A Detailed Comparison
| Features | Genesis | BMW |
| Design | ||
| Gas Mileage | ||
| Repair and Maintenance Cost | ||
| Safety | ||
| Durability | ||
| Technology | ||
| Engine and Performance |
Genesis vs. BMW Reliability: Which Is Better?
Genesis is a relatively new brand in the automotive industry, launched in November 2015 as the luxury division of Hyundai. Despite the short history of this amazing brand, Genesis has risen quickly, establishing itself as a brand to reckon with amongst other luxury car brands.
This is all thanks to their reliability and impressive build quality.
There are no doubts that Genesis is better than BMW in terms of reliability. This is except gas mileage is your sole priority, because there are more BMW vehicles with better gas mileage than Genesis.
According to RepairPal, Genesis has a reliability rating of 3.5/5.0, ranking 7th out of 30 luxury car brands. This is compared to BMW, which takes the 30th position out of 32 car brands, with a reliability rating of 2.5/5.0.
On the 2022 JD Power dependability survey, Genesis earns the gold standard as the most dependable luxury brand with 155 problems per 100 vehicles. This is compared to BMW, which takes the 15th position with 187 problems per 100 problems.
However, BMW pulls a quick one on Genesis by ranking 3rd on the 2022 consumer reports survey, with Genesis taking the 10th position. Although Genesis has a better edge than BMW, you must understand that you need more than reliability ratings to determine the reliability of a car brand.
Genesis beats BMW with better warranty coverage. This implies that you will be saving more money on car maintenance and repairs on Genesis compared to BMW. With Genesis, you are getting a basic 5-year/60,000-mile warranty and a 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranty. BMW, on the other hand, offers a 4-year/50,000-mile basic warranty and a 4-year/50,000-mile powertrain warranty.
Aside from warranty coverage, Genesis offers cheaper repair and maintenance costs. It is highly expected that luxury brands have high repair and maintenance costs, but BMW takes the increased prices to a whole new level.
You are getting higher safety ratings on Genesis, but BMW beats Genesis with better gas mileage. It is important to mention that gas mileage varies on the different models of both brands; however, BMW offers an edge with better fuel economy on most of its vehicles.
Engine performance varies depending on the model that you choose from any of these brands; however, BMW has more vehicles with better gas mileage. The design of these brands varies according to the philosophies and models that you choose.
Genesis vs. BMW Reliability: Design
Design is another crucial factor that many car buyers consider when choosing between different brands. You must understand that comparing the reliability of the design of brands goes beyond style and beauty but includes durability, space, and overall build quality.
Genesis and BMW adopt different design philosophies, impacting the level of designs they churn out. For Genesis, design is all about creation. Every vehicle is an attempt to discover something new. The brand is always attempting to explore innovations and technology, integrating advanced design elements to build something new.
Genesis builds its designs around “athletic elegance,” building an audacious, progressive, and distinct identity that is purely Korean. With the legendary crest grille, quad lamps, parabolic line, and use of white space in the interiors, Genesis vehicles are structured to make a statement on the road.
BMW, on the other hand, is known for producing vehicles with a more conservative design that emphasizes simplicity and elegance. The design philosophy of BMW is centered on sheer driving pleasure, without neglecting the need for traditional performance.
There is an emphasis on form and function. With the use of a long wheelbase, four round headlights, L-shaped rear lights, long hood with great balance, BMW tweaks its designs to adapt to its racing history. However, you are getting good premium designs and a fancy integration of luxury.
BMW sets a good balance of aesthetics, technology, and aerodynamics. However, this varies for a lot of BMW models. For instance, the BMW 4 series adopts a sensual and muscular frame, but the BMW 328 gets a racing history.
Cargo space, head, and legroom vary on BMW and Genesis vehicles; the 2023 Genesis G70 gets lesser cargo space than the 2023 BMW 3 series, but the 2022 Genesis G80 gets more headroom and legroom than the BMW 5 series.
Whether you choose a Genesis or a BMW, you get good designs. The choice is yours to make!
Winner: Both
Genesis vs. BMW Reliability: Engine and Performance
Engine reliability and performance strength go beyond how long an engine will last or how durable it is. It takes into account the driving dynamics, build quality, and overall cost of maintaining the engine.
Both BMW and Genesis offer excellent engines, an amazing boost of power, and a balance of fuel economy. You are getting amazing engineering principles.
However, on an overall scale of reliability between Genesis and BMW, you are getting fewer chances of repairs, higher engine durability, and more power, but BMW gets better gas mileage. This is visible in the engines of most BMW and Genesis models.
For instance: the 2022 Genesis G80 gets a 311hp while the 2022 BMW 5 series returns a 258hp. However, the Genesis G80 returns 23/32 MPG for city and highway while BMW 5 series gets 25/33 MPG, respectively.
The 2022 BMW 530 falls behind the Genesis G70 in engine power with an engine performance of 248hp, while Genesis gets 252 and 365 hp, depending on your engine choice.
It is important to mention that in some cases, BMW has better engines than Genesis. For example, the BMW 3 series wins with an engine performance of 255 hp against Genesis' 252 hp.
Overall, both brands are known for producing vehicles with powerful engines and smooth performance.
Winner: Both
Genesis vs. BMW Reliability: Gas Mileage
In terms of gas mileage, there are no arguments that BMW offers better fuel efficiency than Genesis. With the 2022 BMW 530, you are getting 25/33 MPG compared to the 2023 Genesis G70, which has 21/31 MPG.
The differences are not always that much between Genesis and BMW models, but it is worth mentioning. BMW takes another lead with the 2022 BMW 5 series that delivers 25/33 MPG for city and highway, as against the 2022 Genesis G80 that delivers 23/32 MPG.
Down to Genesis G70 vs. BMW 3 series, it is obvious that BMW is more fuel efficient. You must not forget that gas mileage can vary based on different factors, such as driving habits and terrain.
Winner: BMW
Genesis vs. BMW Reliability: Repair and Maintenance Costs
When it comes to the cost of repairs and maintenance, Genesis is better than BMW. Irrespective of the fact that Genesis and BMW are both luxury brands, BMW vehicles are high-maintenance cars.
According to RepairPal, the average annual repair cost for BMW is $968, while the average annual repair cost for Genesis is $565. With the inclusion of higher warranty coverage on Genesis, it is obvious that you will spend less trying to maintain a Genesis vehicle compared to a BMW.
Irrespective of the cheap repair and maintenance cost, it is obvious that you will spend less maintaining and repairing a Genesis than you will with a BMW.
Winner: Genesis
Genesis vs. BMW Reliability: Safety and Technology
When it comes to safety, Genesis gets the lead with higher safety ratings. According to the IIHS ratings, BMW has five vehicles earning the IIHS Top Safety Pick (+) Award, while Genesis gets seven vehicles in the IIHS Top Safety Pick (+) Award.
Irrespective of the fact that Genesis beats BMW with high safety ratings, you are getting amazing technology on vehicles from both brands.
The technology equipped on vehicles from both brands varies on operations and designs; however, the ultimate goal is to offer comfort, convenience, and safety.
With BMW, you are getting steering and lane control assistance, traffic jam assistance, lane keeping assistance, lane departure warning, and lots more.
This is almost similar to Genesis, which adopts automated highway driving assist, blind spot collision avoidance assist, rear cross-traffic collision avoidance assist, etc. All of these intelligent driving mechanisms are equipped to ensure your safety by including airbag systems.
Whichever brand you choose, you will surely get amazing infotainment systems with touchscreens and smartphone integration.
Winner: Genesis
Conclusion
Genesis is better than BMW when it comes to overall reliability. However, we will advise that before you purchase any car from any of these brands, it is important that you study the models and decide which one is best for you.
Reliability, engine performance, and designs vary across the different brands and models. A test drive will help give you a real-time experience of what to expect.
