Chevy vs Toyota: Which Is More Reliable?

Chevrolet vs Toyota Reliability

Chevy and Toyota are popular brands with a history of making reliable cars. No matter how much we love both car brands, we must compare their reliability.

When it comes to comparing the reliability of Chevy and Toyota, it's important to note that both manufacturers have a history of producing dependable vehicles. So, is Chevy more reliable than Toyota?

The answer is No! Toyota is a more reliable car brand than Chevy. You get higher reliability ratings from Toyota, better safety ratings, and cheaper repair and maintenance costs on Toyota. There are more Toyota vehicles than Chevys.

Read on to find out all you need to know about the comparison between Chevy vs Toyota reliability.

A Detailed Comparison

Rugged and Sporty
Modern and Sleek
Engine and Performance
Fair Safety Ratings
Chevy cars last up to 200,000 to 250,000 miles with an average lifespan of 10-13 years.
Toyota cars last up to 150,000 - 200,000 miles with An average lifespan of 13-17 years.
Repair and Maintenance Cost
Gas Mileage

Which Is Better?

Toyota is known for its high-quality, superb durability, increased efficiency, and popular TQM system. On the other hand, Chevy has maintained a standard of producing affordable cars, with immense engine power. However, there are some key differences to consider.

Most times, to get an accurate understanding of the reliability of Chevy vs Toyota, we will need to compare various models of both brands, citing a variety of factors including gas mileage, design, engine, and performance.

According to RepairPal, Toyota has a reliability rating of 4.0/5.0, ranking 8th out of 32 car brands. Chevy has a 3.5/5.0 rating, ranking 20th out of 32 car brands.

Toyota has higher scores on the 2022 JD Power dependability survey, and also has more cars than Chevy, earning the Consumer Reports 'Excellent' Ratings.

When it comes to overall reliability, it is obvious that Toyota is better than Chevy. According to Consumer Reports,

Although there are areas where both brands come to a tie, Toyota cars do better than Chevy in most categories.

The safety ratings are higher on Toyota, reliability ratings, repair, and maintenance costs, and even the chances of taking your car for major or minor repair are lower on Toyota compared to Chevy.

With a Toyota vehicle, you'll get superior build quality. This is because the brand invests heavily in its engineering principles.


Both Chevy and Toyota have a wide range of vehicles with different designs, from compact cars to full-size trucks. Chevy has a reputation for producing vehicles with a more rugged and sporty design. Toyota is known for producing vehicles with a more sleek and modern look.

Chevy adopts a bold, American design aesthetic. Their vehicles feature sharp lines and a sporty look, with a great focus on power and performance. This is evident in the Chevy Camaro and Corvette.

Toyota has little interest in updating the designs of its cars or the need to constantly redesign to catch the attention of the public.

Their vehicles adopt more practicality and reliability. The designs have a great focus on fuel efficiency, build quality, and utility.

Aside from the differences in design philosophies, Toyota beats Chevy with better engineering principles. The Toyota brand adopts so many Total Quality control measures to ensure durability and reliability.

The brand is strict with quality and most times it appears that Toyota is slow in adopting new technology. This is because Toyota adheres to continuous improvement and believes that rushing into adopting the latest trends without testing their usability will affect the reliability of the brand.

In conclusion, the choice of design reliability lies on your shoulders, whichever brand catches your interest.

Winner: Both

Safety and Technology

When it comes to the safety of Chevy and Toyota cars, both brands have a wide range of amazing features that keep drivers and passengers safe. However, one is safer than the other.

Toyota has 14 cars earning the 2022 IIHS Top Safety Pick (+) award. These cars cut across different categories; large pickups, minivans, midsize SUVs, small SUVs, and large and small cars.

Toyota has a long-standing commitment to safety, and the company has invested heavily in developing advanced safety technologies. For example, Toyota was one of the first car manufacturers to introduce electronic stability control (ESC) as a standard feature across its entire lineup.

Toyota's commitment to advanced safety pays off in the level of reliability that it offers users.

The advanced driver assistance systems which comprise lane departure warning systems, and automatic emergency braking, coupled with the numerous crash tests, there are a lot of reasons to rely on Toyota's safety.

Winner: Toyota

Engine and Performance

When it comes to comparing the reliability of Chevy and Toyota engines and performance, there are a few key differences to consider. Both Chevy and Toyota have a reputation for producing engines that are powerful and reliable.

Chevy offers a wide range of engine options from small four-cylinder engines to powerful V8s. However, their vehicles are known for their V8 engines, which offer strong performance and towing capability on their trucks. Considering Chevy's emphasis on a Sporty feel, their engines focus on Power and acceleration.

Toyota vehicles, on the other hand, tend to have smaller, more fuel-efficient engines that are still capable of providing good performance. It is easier to assume that Toyota engines are underpowered.

In the bid to maintain reliability, Toyota avoids excessive tweaks on its engines to ensure that they last very long without the need to put excessive pressure on them.

Your choice between Chevy and Toyota depends on if you want a burst of power, or you want something that will last longer with fewer issues.

Winner: Both

Repair and Maintenance Cost

It is cheaper to repair and maintain a Toyota than a Chevy. This is without failing to mention that you will have more reasons to visit the repair shop with a Chevy than you will with a Chevy.

According to Repairpal, Toyota gets an annual average repair cost of $441. This is way cheaper than Chevy which has $649. Chevy gets a 15% probability of severe damages, and a 0.3 chance of visiting the repair shop. Toyota has only 12% and 0.2 chances, respectively.

Winner: Toyota

Gas Mileage

When it comes to fuel efficiency, Toyota has a better reputation than Chevy.

The Toyota Prius is one of the most fuel-efficient cars on the market. On the other hand, Chevy vehicles are generally less fuel efficient than Toyota.

The 2022 Toyota Prius is well known for its excellent fuel economy, with an estimated gas mileage of 58 MPG City/53 MPG Highway. The gas mileage Toyota Corolla differs according to the trim level that you choose. You will get 31 city /40 highway MPG on the SE/SE Nightshade trim.

The Toyota Camry Hybrid and Toyota RAV4 Hybrid also offer impressive fuel efficiency, but if you are a fan of hybrid options, you can consider the 2022 Toyota Prius Prime with a gas mileage of MPGe. This is better than the Chevy which gets 106MPGe.

The Chevy Spark also gets great gas mileage, with an estimated gas mileage of 29 mpg for manual transmission and 30 MPG on automatics. The Chevy Malibu Hybrid and Chevy Bolt EV also offer impressive fuel efficiency.

Winner: Toyota


In summary, both Chevy and Toyota offer a wide range of vehicles with different designs, engines, and performance capabilities.

Chevy tends to have less fuel-efficient cars with a more rugged and sporty design, while Toyota is known for its sleek and modern look with more fuel-efficient cars. Although, when it comes to overall reliability, Toyota is better than Chevy, the choice is yours to make.