Toyota Tundra Vs Ford F-150 Reliability

Toyota Tundra vs Ford F-150 Reliability

Toyota's popular pickup trucks, the Toyota Tundra and the Ford F-150 are two of the most popular vehicles in the market. Which is better overall, reliability or value, when choosing a truck?

The Toyota Tundra is an excellent choice for people who need a full-size truck. The Ford F-150, on the other hand, is a more refined and comfortable vehicle. Both of these trucks have their strengths and weaknesses.

Due to the various features and specs of both vehicles, it can be hard to choose between the Toyota Tundra and the Ford F-150. However, it's essential to consider all the factors that will affect your decision.

The article covers everything you need to know about Tundra vs. F150 reliability.

Tundra Vs. F-150 Reliability: Detailed Comparison

Interior and Exterior
More beautiful
3.5-liter V-6
3.5-liter V-6
Better performance
More comfortable
More reliable
Value for money
Gives you better value for money
Great value for money
Towing and hauling
Tows 11,120
Tows 11,300
Gas mileage
18 mpg city/24 mpg highway
19 mpg city/24 mpg highway
Repair and maintenance

Which Is Better: Tundra Vs. F-150?

Toyota's popular pickup truck, the Toyota Tundra, is a great choice for people who need a full-size truck. On the other hand, the Ford F-150 is a more refined vehicle.

Its higher levels of comfort and refinement make it a more practical choice.

Before making a decision, it's important to analyze the factors that make the Toyota Tundra better than the Ford F-150 and vice versa.

In this article, we will talk about the features and capabilities of both vehicles.

Tundra Vs. F-150 Reliability: The Exterior and Interior

At first glance, the Ford F-150 seems to be a more refined vehicle. Although we like the sheet metal of the Toyota Tundra, we can't help but notice its gaping grille.

On the other hand, the Toyota Tundra is more muscular and looks like it has something to prove.

The vertical taillight design of the Toyota Tundra doesn't seem to be as prominent as that of the Ford F-150.

However, it's still a product of the new decade, and Toyota's LED turn signals are modern. The Ford F-150, on the other hand, is 10 years old and will likely be replaced by a new model in 2021.

The interior of the Toyota Tundra is modern. Its infotainment system features a 14-inch screen and attractive sculpted vents and piano-key switches.

The Ford F-150, on the other hand, has plastic buttons and dials that are more dated. However, they're relatively easy to use compared to the Toyota's steering wheel controls and stereo.

The interior of the Ford F-150 is similar to that of the Toyota Tundra in terms of its plastics. However, the majority of its dashboard is made of high-quality materials.

Some of our testers found the F-150's two-tone cloth upholstery more comfortable and attractive.

Although the Ford F-150 and Toyota's infotainment systems feature giant touchscreens, Toyota's features are more powerful.

For instance, Ford's system only shows one display at a time, while Toyota's allows users to use multiple systems simultaneously.

The back seats of the Toyota Tundra and the Ford F-150 are spacious and comfortable. Both vehicles also have two USB ports and a 120v outlet.

The Toyota's rear seats are also more comfortable. Its long bottom cushion provides better leg support and a more relaxed back angle.

The Ford F-150's flexible and flat floor and storage bins made it more practical than the Toyota's large transmission hump and plastic binnacles.

Foldaway storage bins are also available for an additional $215 in the F-150.

Winner: F150

Tundra vs. F-150 Reliability: Power

Both the Toyota and Ford F-150 were equipped with twin-turbo V-6 engines. Toyota's 3.5-liter V-6 is standard on the model, while Ford's 3.6-liter V-6 is only available as an option.

The Ford's optional 3.5-liter V-6 is $2,595 more expensive. On the other hand, the Toyota gets standard all-wheel drive and is powered by a 3.3-liter non-turbo V-6.

The Ford F-150 is a lot more practical than the Toyota. Its 400 horsepower and 500 lb-ft of torque are 11 and 21 lb-ft better than the latter.

It also weighs less than the Toyota. Both the Toyota and Ford F-150 come standard with a 3.31:1 rear axle. However, the Ford tester comes with an optional 3.55:1 gearing.

The various factors contributing to the Ford F-150's impressive speed advantage over the Toyota is its ability to go from 0 to 60 mph in 5.3 seconds.

The Ford feels more powerful on the open road. Its EPA-estimated fuel economy numbers are also better than those of Toyota.

Although the Ford F-150 is more potent than the Toyota, the latter's 10-speed automatic transmission can still perform better during tests.

The Toyota's automatic transmission can smoothly and quickly shift into gear while the Ford struggles to find the right ratio.

Winner: Tundra

Tundra Vs. F-150 Reliability: Performance

Ford gained a significant advantage over Toyota regarding the suspension of its pickup trucks.

Although the Toyota and Ford F-150 can provide a smooth ride, the Toyota's ride worsens as the pavement worsens.

The steering of the Ford F-150 is light and numb, which makes it easy to maneuver, while the Toyota is less precise.

Both Ford and Toyota can use adaptive cruise control, which allows the vehicles to guide themselves in a way that's most comfortable for their human drivers.

However, Toyota's human drivers experience a hard time staying centered.

Winner: F-150

Tundra vs. F-150 Reliability: Comfort

Regarding comfort, the Ford F-150 is better than the Toyota pickup truck. This is because the Ford vehicle offers more room at the rear. However, if you'll be driving the truck all the time, this factor won't matter.

The Ford F-150 is a better choice than the Toyota pickup truck if you're looking for a luxurious vehicle.

Although the latter has more features, the F-150 comes with various standard equipment not found in the base model. These include heated front seats, a steering wheel, and a heated rear seat.

Winner: F150

Tundra Vs. F-150 Reliability: Safety

Toyota's base model, the Toyota Tundra, is considered to be safer than the F-150 due to its standard safety suit. This includes the various features found in the F-150 XL trim.

The Toyota's base model includes various safety features, such as automatic high-beam headlights, adaptive cruise control, and lane departure warning.

The standard features of the F-150 XL include forward collision warning, curve control, and a rear camera with the assist.

Winner: Tundra

Tundra Vs. F-150 Reliability: Reliability

The Ford F-150 is considered one of the world's most popular pickup trucks. However, since it was first introduced in 2015, the vehicle has not received good ratings from Consumer Reports.

Despite this, the Ford F-150 secured 57 out of 100 points from Consumer Reports. Toyota's 2020 model, on the other hand, was able to secure a better overall reliability rating.

Winner: Tundra

Tundra Vs. F-150 Reliability: Value for Money

In this segment, we'll talk about value for money. This is one of the most essential factors you should consider when choosing a new pickup truck. It's also not just because one vehicle is cheaper.

Toyota's base model, the Toyota Tundra, is currently priced at $33,000. On the other hand, the Ford F-150's base model costs around $28,495. With that in mind, the difference between the two models is $4,000.

Although the Toyota vehicle is $4,000 more expensive than the Ford model, it's still better for money.

The F-150 is a stripped-down pickup truck that only comes with minimal and essential features. On the other hand, the Toyota vehicle has more features and is considered more value for money.

The Toyota vehicle also comes with more safety features than the F-150. It also has a standard seven-inch touchscreen display, Bluetooth, and an integrated trailer brake controller.

In addition, the standard audio system includes Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.

Winner: Tundra

Tundra Vs. F-150 Reliability: Towing and Hauling

Ford's F-150 is considered to be the better pickup truck when it comes to towing and payload capacity.

Toyota's vehicle had a maximum towing capacity of 11,120 pounds and a payload of 1,740 pounds. On the other hand, Ford's Max Trailering package can haul up to 2,100 pounds.

Even with a lesser package, the F-150 still out-tows the Toyota vehicle by 180 pounds.

Although the skill and capacity of the two models are different, we've always found the F-150 to be a more stable platform for towing.

Tundra Vs. F-150 Reliability: Gas Mileage

The Toyota Tundra averages 18 miles per gallon in the city and 24 miles per gallon on the highway while the Ford F-150 does 19 mpg city/24 mpg highway.

Winner: Both

Tundra Vs. F-150 Reliability:Repair and Maintenance

The Tundra costs $606 yearly for repairs and maintenance and the F150 costs $788 annually.

Winner: Tundra

Final Verdict

We were expecting close competition between the two models. Toyota clearly established itself as the best in developing the new Toyota vehicle.

It closely followed the tracks of the Ford F-150 when it came to expanding its new platform.

Despite the competition, the Ford F-150 still maintained its position as the best pickup truck. The vehicle's interior is relatively easier to use than the Toyota model.

Also, the F-150's back seat is more comfortable than the Tundra. Despite this, the F-150 still offers more flexibility when carrying other people's cargo.