Jeep vs Subaru: Which Is More Reliable?
I am a serial entrepreneur and a consumer advocate. When I’m not helping car buyers, I love working on ventures that have a positive impact.
I run a cause marketing agency and serve on the board of Vayu Global Health where we are disrupting the medical industry and preventing the needless deaths of mothers and babies during childbirth.
Jeep is an iconic American brand recognized for its toughness and all-terrain capabilities. At the same time, Subaru has a reputation for its durable and practical all-wheel drive vehicles. But the question then becomes: which is more reliable?
RepairPal provides vehicle repair estimates and ratings. They’ve awarded Subaru an average overall reliability rating of 3.5 out of 5. At the same time, Jeep also received a rating of 3.5 out of 5, which is also average.
Remember that reliability may differ significantly among various models and years of each brand. Furthermore, several factors influence it, including maintenance, usage, and driving habits.
Overall, the Subaru edges the Jeep brand in terms of reliability.
In this article, we compare reliability of Jeep vs Subaru!
Table of Contents
Jeep vs. Subaru Reliability: Detailed Comparison
| Features | Jeep | Subaru |
| Design | ||
| Repairs and Maintenance Cost | ||
| Durability | ||
| Engine | ||
| Gas Mileage | ||
| Technology | ||
| Safety |
Which is the Best Car: Jeep or Subaru?
American auto-giant Jeep is known for manufacturing rugged, durable vehicles that handle even the most unforgiving terrain. Models like the Wrangler, Cherokee, Grand Cherokee, and Renegade often include additional features and capabilities for off-roading.
In contrast, Subaru is the brand of choice for reliable, safe, and practical vehicles. Models such as the Impreza, Legacy, Outback, and Crosstrek come complete with all-wheel drive.
For off-roading, Jeeps reign supreme. Thanks to their robust four-wheel drive systems, high ground clearance, and rugged construction, they prove most suitable for treacherous conditions.
Subarus can handle moderate off-road journey, but they’re better suited for everyday use. They offer increased fuel efficiency and practicality.
Jeeps tend to be priced higher than Subarus, with some models hovering around the $50,000 mark.
On the other hand, Subaru models are far more accessible. Prices start at just $20,000.
When deciding between a Jeep or Subaru, it depends on your needs and preferences. If a rugged, off-roading experience is what you’re after, then a Jeep might be the better option. But Suburus offer a safe, durable choice for everyday driving.
Jeep vs. Subaru Reliability: Design
When comparing design preferences, unique qualities of each manufacturer are clear. Subaru stylishly impresses with a functional and user-friendly cabin layout and luxury materials. Jeep impressively flaunts ruggedness and utility.
Tire choices vary between automakers. Jeep is known to offer all-terrain and mud-terrain tires for peak off-road performance, while Subaru provides all-season and performance tires designed for highway and city use.
Personalizing vehicles further, Jeep supplies an array of aftermarket parts and accessories to upgrade off-road capabilities, such as winches and skid plates. At the same time, Subaru provides convenience accessories, like cargo organizers, roof racks, and seat covers.
Overall, Subaru's eye-catching design and materials are the reason why it stands out.
Winner: Subaru
Jeep vs. Subaru Reliability: Repairs and Maintenance Cost
Jeeps, renowned for their off-roading capabilities, demand more specialized parts and repairs. This in turn, leads to higher maintenance costs. Subarus, by contrast, are built for everyday driving. Thus they requires fewer technical parts and repairs.
One factor that affects repair and upkeep costs is the age and condition of the car. Older and extensively used Jeeps and Subarus both need more frequent repairs and maintenance.
Additionally, some models of Jeeps may require higher costs due to electrical system and transmission complications.
The prices of parts and labor varies depending on the model. Jeep parts are often pricier due to their specialty. But additionally, repairs may require a mechanic with specialized experience working with Jeeps.
Conversely, Subaru parts are more available. Repairs often demand less specialized labor.
Routine maintenance, such as oil changes, tire rotations, and brake replacements, can reduce repair costs for Jeeps and Subarus.
In other words, Subaru is cheaper for of repairs and maintenance costs.
Winner: Subaru
Jeep vs. Subaru Reliability: Durability
Jeeps, renowned for their robustness and bold external design, command great respect among off-roading enthusiasts and adventurers.
Equipped with gear such as solid axles and strong drivetrains, these vehicles are fitted to survive even the roughest terrain. Models like the Wrangler and Gladiator are tailored to meet off-roaders' needs.
On the other hand, Subarus, famous for dependability and its all-wheel drive, are favored by commuters and families. Constructed with qualitative components and advanced safety features, they remain a long-lasting car. Many surpass 200,000 miles with good maintenance.
When it comes to durability, both carmakers have their merits. Jeeps are constructed to brave even the harshest environments. Subarus are designed for security and endurance. Ultimately, it depends on individual preferences and the lifestyle of the buyer.
A Jeep is a more suitable option for those driving in rough conditions or living in a region with extreme weather. A Subaru is more suitable for those looking for a dependable car for everyday use.
Winner: Both
Jeep vs. Subaru Reliability: Engine
Jeeps are renowned for their reliable and robust engines, crafted to endure even the most demanding off-road experiences.
The most popular engine in the Jeep selection is the 3.6-liter Pentastar V6, capable of generating up to 285 horsepower and 260 lb-ft of torque. This motor is merged with either a six-speed manual or eight-speed automatic transmission.
Jeep also has a 5.7-liter Hemi V8 in particular models for those who want more power. This motor can create up to 360 horsepower and 390 lb-ft of torque, making it an optimal choice for tugging or hauling heavy cargo.
On the other hand, Subarus are recognized for their fuel-efficient and dependable motors. Their motors provide outstanding fuel economy and all-wheel drive capability.
The most preferred engine in the Subaru range is the 2.5-liter flat-four engine. It’s capable of producing up to 182 horsepower and 176 lb-ft of torque. Depending on the model, this motor is connected to either a six-speed manual or a CVT.
Subaru also features a 2.4-liter turbocharged flat-four engine in chosen models for those seeking a more potent option. This motor can produce up to 260 horsepower and 277 lb-ft of torque. It’s an ideal selection for those needing more power.
Winner: Jeep
Jeep vs. Subaru Reliability: Gas Mileage
Subarus are renowned for its fuel economy. The Impreza and Legacy demonstrate this with significant mpg ratings. The Impreza offers 28 mpg in the city and 36 mpg on highways, while the Legacy says 27 mpg in cities and 35 mpg on highways.
Jeeps, possessing off-road capabilities, have more of a hunger for fuel. But more recent models have improved gas mileage.
For example, the Wrangler has an estimated 22 mpg in cities and 29 mpg on highways. The Cherokee is estimated to have 23 mpg in cities and 31 mpg on highways.
Winner: Subaru
Jeep vs. Subaru Reliability: Technology
Jeep's 4x4 technology, such as the Selec-Terrain and Quadra-Trac, is crafted to supply ideal traction on different terrains.
Select-Terrain permits the driver to pick from five distinct modes depending on the terrain they are driving on, such as snow, sand, or mud.
The Quadra-Trac system is an always-active 4x4 system that continuously furnishes traction to all four wheels. It ensures the highest stability on uneven terrains.
Jeep also presents off-road components like skid plates, locking differentials, and hill descent control, to help drivers navigate complex landscapes with ease.
On the other hand, Subaru possesses a more spectacular method of off-road technology. The symmetrical All-Wheel Drive system is a standard feature in every Subaru car. It gives superior balance and trustworthiness on any terrain.
X-Mode is another technology that augments the Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive system. It optimizes the engine, transmission, and braking systems to ensure maximal traction and power while traveling on slippery or bumpy roads.
EyeSight is yet another exclusive technology featured by Subaru. It’s a compilation of driver-assist functions that uses cameras and sensors to oversee the roadway and environment. It notifies the driver of potential risks and helps to avoid crashes.
Winner: Subaru
Jeep vs. Subaru Reliability: Safety
Jeep and Subaru are highly regarded car companies with enormous fan bases for their dependable and safe vehicles. When weighing safety, which one reigns supreme?
Jeep vehicles are well known for their off-road capacities and durability, making them perfect for romping through the great outdoors. Unfortunately, their safety ratings don't match up to their competition. Recent years have seen improvements in safety features. However, they still have some catching up to do.
On the contrary, Subaru has continually achieved outstanding safety scores from sources including the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). It also received praise for its safety developments, like its EyeSight driver assistance system and all-wheel drive technology.
One fundamental distinction stands out when comparing Jeep and Subaru safety. While Jeep prioritizes ruggedness and off-road worthiness over safety systems, Subaru emphasizes safety first.
Subaru models come stocked with standard safety amenities such as rearview cameras, blind spot monitoring, and all-wheel drive. These are often optional or unavailable on Jeeps.
Of course, Jeep has models that perform strongly on safety tests. An example is the Jeep Cherokee. It was given top safety ratings from the IIHS. Nevertheless, Subaru surpasses Jeep as a brand when it comes to safety.
Winner: Subaru
Final Verdict
The Subaru is a more reliable brand than the Jeep. The Jeep is far from a bad car, but in terms of reliability, it falls short of the Subaru.
