Jaguar vs Mercedes Reliability

https://www.findthebestcarprice.com/author-chris-cho

Chris Cho

Chris Cho

Chris is Head of Content for FindTheBestCarPrice and is based out of Philadelphia, PA. As a seasoned automotive industry analyst and car enthusiast, he ensures the highest level of quality across all our content and curates our picks for the best deals each month.
Chris studied information systems and marketing at Drexel University and writes about a wide range of topics ranging from car buying tips to troubleshooting common mechanical issues.

When he’s not thinking about cars, he likes to stay in with his dog and make an “attempt” to finish a crossword puzzle (he’s not quite at the Saturday/Sunday level…yet). As a former cheesemonger, Chris still has a “sharp” passion for all things cheese, and his fridge is always loaded with it!

Mercedes-Benz is recognized for its automotive safety innovations, and Jaguar is another highly-perceived luxury car brand.

But is Jaguar or Mercedes more reliable?

Read on as we outline different features and determine who comes out top in the Jaguar vs Mercedes reliability comparison.

Jaguar vs Mercedes Reliability: Detailed Comparison

Which is the Best Car: Jaguar or Mercedes?

The debate regarding Jaguar vs Mercedes reliability has fascinated car enthusiasts and casual observers alike for decades.

Despite having its groups of loyalists, each company presents a distinct blend of style, performance, and reliability that sets them apart.

Mercedes-Benz's unwavering allegiance to innovation and engineering prowess is widely acknowledged. It shows this with its excellent reliability rating and state-of-the-art safety systems.

The brand's peerless dedication to quality is unparalleled, matched solely by its meticulous attention to detail. Ultimately, it yields a fleet of vehicles that exude luxury and sophistication in every aspect.

On the other hand, Jaguar has built its reputation on a storied legacy of uncompromising style and performance. It uses only the most premium materials in constructing its automobiles.

The marque's distinctive design language, distinguished by its sleek lines and graceful curves, has evolved into an emblem of the brand and a representation of its steadfast dedication to elegance and refinement.

In conclusion, the decision between these two renowned brands is subjective. Each showcases its distinct strengths and attributes that cater to diverse drivers.

Whether prioritizing reliability and safety or style and performance, there is no denying that both Jaguar and Mercedes cemented their place in automotive greatness. So, which is the best car?

1. Jaguar vs. Mercedes Reliability: Design

Jaguar is deeply committed to crafting designs that stimulate an enchanting narrative, endeavoring to enrich lives through lucid and refined aesthetics.

The brand's unique automobiles evoke profound emotional connections. They constantly push boundaries with their distinctive and dynamic proportions, graceful curves, and impressive road performance.

Passengers get a remarkable experience thanks to the stunning silhouette that radiates grandeur and drama.

Time and time again, Jaguar's innovative design delivers sheer elegance, exhilarating proportions, and superb performance.

Mercedes-Benz designs future cars while reconciling traditional and modern aspects. The brand is committed to sensual purity and modern luxury, which is at its core.

The focus is increasingly shifting towards emotional, authentic experiences, a reduction to what is essential. It combines high tech with traditional craftsmanship and genuine pleasure.

Mercedes-Benz is the winner regarding modern luxury and innovative design.

Winner: Mercedes

2. Jaguar vs. Mercedes Reliability: Repair and Maintenance Cost

During the first decade of ownership, Jaguar vehicles accumulate an average maintenance and repair expense of $17,636. This figure exceeds the mean cost for luxury brands by $5,592.

Over the same time frame, Mercedes-Benz vehicles amass an average of $15,986 in expenses for maintenance and repairs. This exceeds the norm for luxury brands by $3,942.

Given the information above, Mercedes-Benz boasts a slight edge in terms of upkeep and repair expenditures compared to Jaguar.

Winner: Mercedes

3. Jaguar vs. Mercedes Reliability: Durability

Jaguar vehicles gained a reputation for their extraordinary durability. Most are, capable of enduring for at least 150,000 miles. With proper maintenance, like routine oil changes, belt replacements, and spark plug replacements, they can surpass 200,000 miles.

The Jaguar's Reliability Rating of 2.5 out of 5.0 positions it at a meager 29th out of 32 car brands. That indicates its low reliability compared to its peers.

In contrast, Mercedes-Benz vehicles can endure up to 15-17 years when subjected to proper care and upkeep. It boasts an average reliability rating of 3.0 out of 5.0 based on patron feedback.

The Mercedes lineup, characterized by a fusion of velocity, potency, elegance, and refinement, wields a formidable presence in the luxury car industry.

Winner: Mercedes

4. Jaguar vs. Mercedes Reliability: Engine

The V6 powertrains of Jaguar's F-TYPE feature a compact supercharger with advanced boost control and a secondary throttle valve.

The 340PS and 380PS engine options produce 450Nm and 460Nm of torque, respectively, enabling acceleration times of 5.3 and 4.9 seconds to reach 0-100km/h.

Meanwhile, the V8 engines are the epitome of potency, equipped with dual independent variable cam timing to optimize power at any velocity.

The 5.0-liter V8 engine generates an impressive 680Nm of torque, while the F-TYPE SVR's 575PS engine produces an astonishing 700Nm of torque.

This enables it to achieve 0-100km/h in a mere 3.7 seconds. Jaguar powertrains are typically coupled with an 8-speed quick-shift automatic transmission and an all-wheel-drive system to enhance their performance in any driving scenario.

Jaguar's F-TYPE offers a wide range of engines, including a 2.0-liter 300PS 4-cylinder turbocharged petrol engine equipped with intelligent continuously variable valve lift control, an E-wastegate, and other features.

On the other hand, the Mercedes-Benz S 400 d boasts the most powerful diesel engine ever produced by Mercedes-Benz. It delivers 250 kW (340 hp) and 700 Nm of torque (combined fuel consumption: 5.2 l/100 km; combined CO2 emissions: 135 g/km).

Furthermore, the newly developed Mercedes-AMG 2.0-litre M 139 engine outputs up to 310 kW (421 hp). This makes it the world's most powerful turbocharged four-cylinder engine in series production.

Overall, the F-TYPE's powerful V8 engines make it the winner in terms of sheer performance, while the Mercedes-Benz engines excel in fuel efficiency and cutting-edge technology.

Winner: Jaguar

5. Jaguar vs. Mercedes Reliability: Gas Mileage

The CT4 Sport generates an impressive 235 horsepower while maintaining an excellent fuel economy of 34 mpg on the highway and 23 mpg in the city.

Meanwhile, the Jaguar 3.0L I6 Turbocharged engine boasts an outstanding fuel economy of 27 mpg on the highway and 20 mpg in the city.

The 2022 Jaguar F-Pace S model surpasses all other models with its exceptional fuel efficiency and noteworthy gas mileage.

On the other hand, Mercedes-Benz models are renowned for their spirited performance, lavish fittings, and top-of-the-line features. But their highly fuel-efficient vehicles are often overlooked.

The 2022 Mercedes-Benz CLA Coupe boasts an impressive highway MPG of 36, while the 2022 Mercedes-Benz A-Class Sedan and GLA SUV offer 35 and 34 highway MPG, respectively. Finally, the 2022 Mercedes-Benz GLB SUV provides a respectable 32 highway MPG.

Winner: Mercedes

6. Jaguar vs. Mercedes Reliability: Technology

Jaguar's InControl system offers drivers an intuitive user interface with an 8-inch high-resolution touchscreen display, Bluetooth connectivity, and detailed 2D/3D maps.

For a more advanced and seamless experience, the InControl Touch Pro system has a larger 10.2-inch screen and advanced voice controls.

Additionally, InControl Remote & Protect allows for remote access to vehicle functions. The InControl Protect provides an SOS button and other safety features to optimize driver assistance.

On the other hand, Mercedes-Benz offers its Mbrace system. This allows drivers to connect to their car from their smartphone or computer.

This system enables drivers to stay connected on the road with a range of apps right in the car. Meanwhile, the Mercedes-Benz COMAND system offers a central controller and a 7-inch display that brings audio, available navigation, and more to drivers' fingertips. Standard features include Bluetooth audio streaming and a USB input.

Jaguar's InControl and Mercedes-Benz's Mbrace systems offer drivers connectivity and features that enhance their driving experience.

Winner: Both

7. Jaguar vs. Mercedes Reliability: Safety

Jaguar automobiles have an all-inclusive InControl safety suite. It provides various safety features, such as emergency braking, lane departure warning, and adaptive cruise control with queue assist.

Depending on the model, drivers can also take advantage of additional features like Park Assist, High-Speed Emergency Braking, Lane Keep Assist, Traffic Sign Recognition, Driver Condition Monitor, Blind Spot Monitor, Blind Spot Assist, Front and Rear Parking Aid, Rear Traffic Monitor, Surround Camera System, and Rear View Camera.

Mercedes-Benz engineers have dedicated their time to developing innovative safety technologies to protect drivers and passengers.

With Mercedes-Benz Intelligent Drive, a multi-purpose camera with 6D Vision technology and an array of sensors monitor the environment around your vehicle, constantly ready to take evasive action and protect everyone on the road.

Adaptive Braking Technology ensures you can stop safely, with Predictive Brake Priming anticipating sudden stops and Automatic Brake Drying, removing water from brake discs in rainy conditions.

Winner: Mercedes

Final Verdict

After analyzing the different factors of reliability, it’s clear that Mercedes is more reliable than Jaguar.

With a higher reliability rating, lower cost of ownership, and more outstanding durability, Mercedes outperforms Jaguar in many aspects.

While Jaguar vehicles are generally reliable, they cannot match the level of reliability offered by Mercedes.