Buick vs. Ford Reliability: A Detailed Comparison
Chris is Head of Content for FindTheBestCarPrice and is based out of Philadelphia, PA. As a seasoned automotive industry analyst and car enthusiast, he ensures the highest level of quality across all our content and curates our picks for the best deals each month.
Chris studied information systems and marketing at Drexel University and writes about a wide range of topics ranging from car buying tips to troubleshooting common mechanical issues.
When he’s not thinking about cars, he likes to stay in with his dog and make an “attempt” to finish a crossword puzzle (he’s not quite at the Saturday/Sunday level…yet). As a former cheesemonger, Chris still has a “sharp” passion for all things cheese, and his fridge is always loaded with it!
Deciding between Buick and Ford vehicles can be difficult. But one of the biggest deciding factors to consider is reliability.
Buick's reliability rating is 3.5 out of 5.0, ranking 13th out of 32 car brands. Consumer Reports states that some Buicks perform well in reliability tests, with Buick being among the most dependable domestic automakers, second only to Lincoln.
Ford's reliability rating, according to RepairPal, is also 3.5 out of 5.0, ranking 21st out of 32 car brands. People admire Ford because they value the quality, value, and efficiency of Ford vehicles. Polk research indicates Ford prioritizes customer satisfaction in design, quality, and value.
This article will examine various aspects of Buick vs. Ford's reliability, such as design, technology, and durability, to comprehend why several people believe Buicks are more reliable than Ford.
Table of Contents
Buick vs. Ford Reliability: Detailed Comparison
| Features | Buick | Ford |
| Design | ||
| Repairs and Maintenance Cost | ||
| Durability | ||
| Engine | ||
| Gas Mileage | ||
| Technology | ||
| Safety |
Which Is the Best Car: Buick or Ford?
Determining the superior automobile between Buick and Ford is a complex question with a multifaceted answer. It is subjective and varies depending on individual preferences and priorities. However, a comprehensive analysis of various factors can aid in discerning which car is better.
When considering Buick vs. Ford's reliability, there are compelling arguments to be made for both brands. According to recent ratings by RepairPal, Buick ranks 13th out of 32 for all car brands regarding reliability, while Ford ranks 21st.
However, Ford has a reputation for quality, value, and efficiency, as recognized by customers and confirmed by Polk research.
When it comes to performance, both Buick and Ford offer impressive options. Buick is known for its smooth ride and comfortable interiors, while Ford has a reputation for powerful engines and sporty handling.
In terms of design, Buick has been praised for its sleek, modern aesthetic, while Ford has a more classic, rugged look.
Ultimately, the choice between Buick and Ford depends on individual preferences and priorities. Some may value reliability and comfort above all else, while others may prioritize performance and style.
1. Buick vs. Ford Reliability: Design
The Buick brand is renowned for its refined and sophisticated aesthetic that exudes classic elegance. Its exterior design is marked by clean lines and understated luxury that creates a timeless and tasteful look, appealing to those who appreciate a more conservative style.
In addition, the brand's interior design features high-quality materials and intuitive technology features that enhance the driving experience.
On the other hand, Ford's kinetic design philosophy has revolutionized the look of Ford's models across the range since its implementation in 2004.
This design approach aims to achieve a constant appearance of motion, even when the car is still, with bold, dynamic lines and full surfaces.
Each model that embraces Ford's kinetic design is intended to provoke an emotional response to its aesthetic, with the ambition that people will see a Ford car and instinctively think, "I want one."
In terms of design, while Buick exudes classic elegance, Ford's kinetic design philosophy creates visually striking and attractive cars that provoke an emotional response.
Winner: Ford
2. Buick vs. Ford Reliability: Repair and Maintenance Cost
Buick models during their first decade of service are estimated to cost $9,063 to maintain and repair. This is $2,249 less than the industry average for famous car brands. However, the probability of requiring significant repairs is moderately high, at 21.13%.
Comparatively, the cost of maintaining and repairing Ford models during their initial ten years of service is estimated at around $9,860, exceeding the industry average for famous car brands by $3,046. Additionally, there is a 22.36% probability of a significant repair being necessary within this period.
Based on the cost of maintenance, Buick is the more cost-effective option. However, the difference in cost is relatively small, and both brands still pose a moderate risk of requiring significant repairs.
Winner: Buick
3. Buick vs. Ford Reliability: Durability
Buick vehicles have earned an impressive reputation for durability and consistency, with drivers lauding their longevity and resilience, with an average lifespan of up to 200,000 miles.
Many Buick owners have attested to their vehicles surpassing the 150,000 to 200,000-mile mark. A select few even reached the 250,000-mile milestone with minimal hassle, subject to regular maintenance and attentive care.
On the other hand, Ford vehicles generally last around 200,000 miles or 13 years. This places them in the upper echelon of the automotive industry.
Additionally, Ford ranks 10th in J.D. Power's 2020 vehicle dependability study, surpassing the industry norm and competitors like Ram, Dodge, and Jeep.
Winner: Buick
4. Buick vs. Ford Reliability: Engine
Buick's engineering prowess is exemplified by its exceptional six-cylinder turbocharged engine, which boasts a remarkable 404 horsepower output.
The variable valve timing (VVT) technology balances power and fuel efficiency, enhancing the car's performance and handling. Buick's commitment to engineering excellence is unmatched.
Conversely, Ford proffers many engine options with varying magnitudes and compositions, including the highly favored V-8 engines, such as the 429 and 460.
However, their most impressive offering is the 2020 Mustang Shelby GT500, which boasts 760 horsepower and 625 lb-ft of torque, making it the most powerful street-legal Ford ever.
In addition, the Ford Figo has two diesel and two petrol engines, ranging from 1194 cc to 1499 cc, and offers both manual and automatic transmission.
Winner: Ford
5. Buick vs. Ford Reliability: Gas Mileage
Buick's gas mileage is remarkable, with an impressive 22 MPG in the city and 29 MPG on the highway, courtesy of advanced fuel-saving technology.
The model features an automatic start-stop system that deactivates the engine when the vehicle is stationary, substantially preserving fuel. Furthermore, its streamlined design optimizes fuel efficiency by minimizing drag and turbulence.
The 2022 Ford Transit Connect Van FWD has a combined MPG of 22, with city MPG rated at 20 and highway MPG at 26, consuming 4.5 gallons of gas per 100 miles.
The 2022 Ford Transit Connect Wagon LWB FWD and the 2022 Ford Transit Connect USPS have the same fuel efficiency ratings as the Transit Connect Van FWD.
However, the 2022 Ford Transit Connect Van FWD has a higher fuel efficiency rating than the previous models, with a combined MPG of 25 and city MPG rated at 24, showcasing Ford's commitment to improving fuel-saving technology.
Winner: Buick
6. Buick vs. Ford Reliability: Technology
Buick's Connected Vehicle Plan offers diverse connectivity options catering to modern drivers' preferences. The In-Vehicle Apps feature provides users with an extensive selection of options, including Reese's Book Club and Alexa Built-in, while the Remote Access Plan enhances user convenience.
The In-Vehicle Wi-Fi Hotspot data feature ensures a dependable connection for up to seven devices, and the myBuick mobile app facilitates remote vehicle functions.
In contrast, FordPass Connect features a built-in modem that offers connectivity on par with a home network. Coupled with the FordPass app, this technology unlocks various connected features that are even more powerful.
Ford SYNC technology allows drivers to manage several connected vehicle features through a touchscreen or simple voice commands, including phone calls, text messages, navigation, and music.
However, the new SYNC 4A in the all-electric Mustang Mach-E is the most innovative system. SYNC 4A boasts cloud-based connectivity and over-the-air updates, making it Ford's most intelligent system yet.
It offers a seamless and continuously evolving customer experience, ensuring drivers always have the latest features and updates.
Winner: Ford
7. Buick vs. Ford Reliability: Safety
Buick's most recent vehicle lineup boasts a diverse range of conventional safety features, including forward collision warning, lane departure warning, and automatic emergency braking, which endow drivers with an additional stratum of security while on the road.
In addition, Buick's innovative safety package, encompassing rear cross-traffic alert, a 360-degree camera system, and adaptive cruise control, bolsters safety measures to provide drivers with the utmost degree of protection.
In contrast, Ford's Intelligent Protection System (IPS) is a seamlessly coordinated safety system activated in a split second to guarantee the safety of both the driver and passengers.
The IPS incorporates many active and passive safety components, such as electronic brake-force distribution, anti-lock braking, traction control, advanced seatbelts, airbags, and the pedal intrusion prevention system to provide the highest level of safety possible.
Winner: Buick
Final Verdict
According to the article, both brands were evenly matched in most Buick vs. Ford reliability categories.
However, in the end, Buick outperformed Ford in four out of seven categories, establishing itself as the more reliable brand.
